Mr. Smith’s Hips
Published by: Andre Shinabarger
December 17, 2009

Mop

I have been working at an urban health center that serves the poor and underserved in Atlanta for 3 years now. In making this decision to work here, I desired to learn a lot about complex medical diseases and hopefully make a difference in showing my patients they deserved quality medical care, even if they couldn’t afford it. What I was not prepared for was a daily position of advocacy and really needing to “fight” for my patients to receive proper medical care.

Mr. Smith (name has been changed to protect patient privacy), is one such example. If there is one thing I accomplish at this current medical center, it is that this man gets the surgery he needs.

Mr. Smith, a 52 year old African American male, first came to me because he was having some hip pain. In our conversation I immediately noticed his sweet demeanor, kind smile, and quiet determination to continue to work through this pain he was experiencing. As I asked more questions, I found out that he was a janitor at a church for the last 25 years and the church did not provide him any health insurance. He didn’t mind though, because he really has been healthy and not needed any medical care. For 25 years he has been moving tables and chairs for church banquets, cleaning Sunday school rooms, and vacuuming the church floors. Throughout our visit he made it very clear that he wanted to figure out what was happening with his hips and return to work as soon as possible.

Well, this hip pain turned out to be a very serious condition called Avascular Necrosis, which is basically a deterioration of his hip bones that can only be fixed by getting hip replacement surgery. For the next 6 months, Mr. Smith’s hips rapidly worsened till finally he was unable to walk and came to his appointments in a wheelchair. He is now unable to work and his brother had to move from New York to help care for him, and I was unable to get him the surgery he needed since he did not have insurance.

We are now in the process of applying for disability, so that maybe he can get disability insurance and possibly get the surgery. Mr. Smith always is the one to remind me that he will return to work as soon as he gets this surgery.

As I watched him deteriorate every month, I found myself enraged with the injustice of the situation, even angry at the church for not helping this man who faithfully served the church for the last 25 years, and fighting for this man’s right to continue to work as a janitor (something that he loved). I call the head of the surgery department monthly to plead for the importance of the surgery, I fill out pages and pages of disability papers, and I strive to keep Mr. Smith’s hope alive that the surgery will happen. Now I know that this is not the church’s or medical institution’s fault—this is just a situation gone bad with no one person to blame.

As I was thinking about him this morning and thinking that a whole year has now gone by and he still has not gotten his surgery, I do not feel like a failure, I have tried, I have persisted and I have fought and will continue to fight for this man, and I know that he is thankful for someone fighting for him when he was unable.

I think we all have someone like this that we know in our life, someone that needs a voice, and needs someone to jump on their side and fight for something with them. Maybe it is just for that person to not feel alone, or maybe it is for justice to prevail in their life. Who is this person in your life? What will you do today?

  • http://topsy.com/tb/bit.ly/8Kbsch Tweets that mention Mr. Smith’s Hips « Plywood People — Topsy.com

    [...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Jeff Shinabarger, Plywood. Plywood said: Mr. Smith’s Hips http://bit.ly/8Kbsch [...]

  • Gisele

    I think it is a great post! I’m wrestling with the story internally. It’s frustrating to me that the church isn’t helping him. It’s awful and humiliating, but at the same time, when I am honest and real, I know that I am as responsible as anyone else every time I hoard what I’ve been blessed enough to receive.

  • Jeff Shinabarger

    Most days in my life, I don’t have to wrestle with this because of the privilege I receive in every aspect of my life. I don’t even realize it because I get my way and I don’t think twice about it. If I was threatened by a situation like this I would demand a different outcome. But, you brought up such a compelling story of the people that don’t get a choice. They don’t get a voice. They don’t get a chance. They are not heard. Do I care? I wonder if I needed the same surgery if I would let this person go before me? To be honest, I probably would be fighting for my own recover, not for the well being of the person in great need net to me. Thanks for writing this – my selfish demeanor is being challenged to the core of who I am. Thinking about these questions from a personal account more than a social issue makes me actually change my worldview.

  • Judy Shinabarger

    How much does hip surgery cost…thousands, I know. And gift cards won’t do it. I’ll be willing to donate, if somehow the money could be raised. He has a lifetime ahead of him and sounds like the neatest guy. Thanks for you caring heart, Andre.

  • Sandy Ten Hoeve

    Thanks for reminding me of my white priveledge and blinders. I can go through my whole day, or week or month or year never being touched by the injustice that is right here in America, while I remain in my white world. I am ashamed….again. I would love to donate for his surgery also. Andre, I’m so proud of your persistence and love and continued fight for this man. I’ll be praying for a breakthrough in this situation….

Here’s What’s Next
Here’s What’s Next

Join 400 influencers & problem solvers for a collaborative gathering in Atlanta.

Partners

Recycled Billboard Wallets
Recycled Billboard Wallets

Buy a Wallet. Help a Widow. Handmade creation, no two wallets are the same.

Goods